DALLAS — For 327 halcyon days, Juan Soto was a New York Yankee.
It was a glorious, swashbuckling tenure. One filled with swaggering acts of baseballing dominance — no-doubt homers and defiant bases on balls and gestures of love to hordes of adoring bleacher creatures. A perfect match, they said. Soto, a monumental player born to play for baseball’s most monumental outfit. In ALCS Game 5, with an at-bat for the ages and a swing for the books, Soto sent the Yankees to the World Series. It all felt like just the beginning.
Late Sunday night, that joyride came to a sudden, thudding and definitive end.
Mets owner Steve Cohen extended an eye-popping, paradigm-shifting, 15-year, $765 million contract to make that possible. It is not just the largest deal in MLB history; it’s the largest deal in sports history. Cohen, one of the planet’s 100 richest souls, was willing to reach heretofore unthinkable heights to bring Soto to Queens. He outbid the Yanks, plain and simple.
Yankees owner Hal Steinbrenner’s best offer, per ESPN, was 16 years, $760 million, around $4 million less per year than the final deal. That’s a strong offer, one that should keep understandably ravenous Yankees fans off Steinbrenner’s tail, but nobody is raising a “we tried” banner in the Bronx.
Can the Yankees craft a competitive team in the wake of Soto’s departure? Absolutely. The Bombers still employ Aaron Judge, the best hitter in the world, and Gerrit Cole, one of the best pitchers in the world. There are enough needle-moving free agents left available to reinforce that core. Adding, say, left-handed starter Max Fried, first baseman Christian Walker, right fielder Teoscar Hernández and a veteran reliever or two would help the Yankees stay a formidable force. Some, though likely not all, of the 750-odd million set aside for Soto will be reallocated elsewhere.
That said, it will be nearly impossible to make up for Soto’s offensive production. No single player provides that combination of power, on-base skill and sheer intimidation; that’s why he just got paid $765 million. The Yankees will attempt, as the Moneyball mantra goes, to replace him in the aggregate. And on a purely statistical level, they might be able to. When it comes to roster construction, there remain paths to salvation for Steinbrenner and general manager Brian Cashman.
This embedded content is not available in your region.
But from a public relations slant, losing Soto is an…